Tuesday, 6 February 2018

Pneumatology of the Book of Revelation




Introduction:
The importance of the Holy Spirit is seen in the fact that His first appearance in Scripture is in the second verse of Genesis 1 and the last is found in the early verses of the closing paragraph of the book of Revelation 22. In between these two points of the Bible His Divine Person is referred to many times. The Spirit plays a significant role in the book of Revelation. The book itself begins and ends with references to the Spirit. In this closing book of the Bible, there are various fascinating aspects of His work to be considered regarding the importance of the Person, presence and power of the Holy Spirit. What significant aspects have the book of Revelation talks about the spirit? What are the roles played by the Holy Spirit? This paper tends to study on the pneumatlogy of the book of Revelation.

1. Pneumatology in the Book of Revelation:
The references to the spirit of God in the Apocalypse can be divided into three categories. Firstly, there are four occurrences of the phrase ἐν πνεύματι (Rev.1:10, 4:2, 17:3, 21:10). Secondly, there are ten occurrences to the spirit (Rev.2:7, 11, 17, 29, 3:6, 13, 22, 14:13, 19:10, 22:17). Thirdly, there are four references to the seven spirits (Rev.1:4, 3:1, 4:5, 5:6).[1]

1.1. The Spirit of Vision:
Under this spirit of vision we will look at the four occurrences of the phrase ‘in the spirit’ (ἐν πνεύματι).[2] In early Christian literature the phrase ἐν πνεύματι commonly means ‘in the spirit’s control.’ Frequently it denotes temporary experience of the spirit’s power in prophetic speech or revelation without specifying any particular mode of the spirit’s operation. In Rev.1:10, 4:2, the expression ἐν πνεύματι is best understood as a technical term for visionary’s experience of ‘rapture’ by the Spirit. John remains a free agent throughout his visions. But the visionary experience is nonetheless necessarily a suspension of normal consciousness. John was ἐν πνεύματι in the sense that his normal sensory experience was replaced by visions and auditions given him by the Spirit.[3] The context requires that Rev.4:2 refer to John’s rapture to heaven. This is an experience which the apocalyptic seers commonly described in more elaborate terms, and it may be significant that John prefers an expression which attributes it to the agency of the Spirit. The idea of the Spirit of God as the agent of visionary experience is occasional in the Old Testament (Num.24:2). More important are the prominence of the Spirit in Ezekiel’s experiences of visionary rapture (Eze.3:2, 14, 8:3, 11:1 etc) and the specification of dreams and visions as the manifestation of the eschatological outpouring of the Spirit in Joel 2:28. In later Jewish literature, the Spirit inspires prophetic speech and visions.[4] The language of Rev.17:3, 21:10 are compared with passages from Jewish and early Christian writings.[5] The closest parallels to these verses of Revelation are Ezekiel 37:1 and Bel 36., and these suggests that ἐν πνεύματι may be instrumental in Revelation 17:3, 21:10. John’s usage is seen to be conventional terminology for visionary transportation obviously modeled on Ezekiel 40:2, he prefers ἐν πνεύματι to ‘in visions of God’ which is found in that verse of Ezekiel.[6] John’s stress on the Spirit’s agency in his visionary experience is a little stronger than appears to have been normal in the Jewish apocalyptics. It is clearly seen that the whole revelation came to John in spirit ‘ἐν πνεύματι’ what we heard and saw was the revelation of Jesus Christ which God gave to him to show to his servants what must soon take place. Experiences of rapture to heaven and visionary transportation were not uncommon in Jewish apocalyptic mysticism and pagan religious experience. But in the claim that it took place under the control of the Spirit and came to him through Jesus Christ from God. In primitive Christianity prophetic vision ἐν πνεύματι was a manifestation of the outpouring of the Spirit in the last days (Joel 2:28). John’s vision was to do so for the seven churches of Asia in their specific historical circumstances in the reign of Domitian. They were to show the meaning in those circumstances of living towards the coming of Christ.[7]

1.2. The Spirit of Prophecy:
In post-biblical Judaism the Spirit is especially the Spirit of prophecy, the Spirit who speaks through the prophets. In Revelation also the Spirit is almost exclusively the Spirit of prophecy. The Spirit of prophecy speaks through the Christian prophets bringing the word of the exalted Christ to his people on earth and directing the prayers of the churches to their heavenly Lord. These are the special functions of the Christian prophets, whom Revelation distinguishes as a special group within the churches (Rev.11:18, 16:6, 18:20, 24, 22:9). The Spirit in the Apocalypse has sometimes been felt to be deficient in that the Spirit is only the Spirit of prophecy rather than moral or life giving power in Christian life. However it should be remarked that the Spirit of prophecy is envisaged as having life giving and life changing effects. For the Spirit brings to the churches the powerful word of Christ, rebuking, encouraging, promising and threatening, touching and drawing the hearts, minds and consciences of its hearers, directing the lives and the prayers of the Christian communities towards the coming of Christ.[8] There is a sense in which the church as a whole has a prophetic vocation. One reason for suspecting is the relationship between prophecy and the phrase, ‘the witness Jesus bore.’ Thus when Rev.19:10 says that ‘the witness of Jesus is the Spirit of prophecy,’ this statement must mean that the witness Jesus bore is the content of Spirit inspired prophecy. It is also therefore the content of John’s own prophecy, the Apocalypse itself (Rev.1:2). The word of God which John’s prophecy communicates is attested primarily by Jesus himself (Rev.22:20), as also by the angel who communicates it to John (Rev.22:16) and by John (Rev.1:2). This word of God is also that to which Jesus bore witness in his earthly life (Rev.1:5) and to which his followers now bear witness in the world (Rev.1:9). Those who bear witness are not just prophets (Rev.19:10) but Christians in general (Rev.12:17).[9] Yet in Rev.11:3, the faithful church in its witness to the world is portrayed under the image of ‘my two witnesses’ who ‘prophesy’ (cf. Rev.11:10), which seems that prophecy and witness are equated. Therefore, the characterization of the Christian community as those who bear the witness of Jesus seems to attribute a role to the whole church. The Spirit speaks through the prophets to the churches and through the churches to the world.[10]

1.3. The Seven Spirits:
Another category of references to the Spirit in Revelation are those to the seven Spirits (Rev.1:4, 3:1, 4:5, 5:6). The identity of these Spirits in Rev.1:4 ‘the seven Spirit’s who are before God’s throne,’ have sometimes been identified not as the divine Spirit but as the seven principal angels who in Jewish angelology, stand in the presence of God in heaven. But Revelation itself refers to these seven angels (Rev.8:2) in terms quite different from the way it refers to the seven Spirits. Although the term Spirit could certainly be used of angels, it rarely has this meaning in early Christian literature and never in Revelation.[11] The Spirits should be understood as a symbol for the divine Spirit, which John has chosen on the basis of his exegesis of Zechariah 4:1-14, a passage which lies behind not only the four references to the seven Spirits but also the description of the two witnesses in Rev.11:4. It seems to have been the key Old Testament passage for John’s understanding of the role of the Spirit in the divine activity of the world. In Zachariah’s vision he is shown a golden lampstand on which are seven lamps. Beside the lampstand are two olive trees (Zach.4:3). Zachariah ask about the identity of the seven lamps and olive trees. These seven lamps are the eyes of the Lord which range through the whole earth (Zach.4:10). John took this sequence to mean that the seven lamps symbolize the seven eyes of the Yahweh which are the divine Spirit.[12] In John’s vision of heaven he sees seven lamps burning before the divine throne which he identifies as the seven Spirits (Rev.4:5). As the seven lamps before the throne in heaven, the seven Spirits belong to the divine being. This is why the reference to them in the Trinitarian blessing of 1:4-5 is also to the seven Spirits who are before his throne.’[13]

However if these references associate the seven Spirits with God, in Rev.5:6 they are very closely associated with the Lamb who is said to have seven horns and seven eyes which are the seven Spirits of God sent out into all the earth. Revelation 5:6 identifies the seven Spirits with both the seven horns and the seven eyes of the Lamb. The connection between God’s all seeing eyes and his power, John makes explicit by adding seven horns, the symbol of strength, to the seven eyes. Likewise, in revelation, the seven horns are the divine power set against the horns of the dragon and the beasts (Rev.12:3, 13:1, 17:12-13).[14] The seven horns and the seven eyes belong to the description of the Lamb when he first appears in Revelation as the slaughtered Lamb who has conquered (Rev.5:5-6). They represent the power of his victory. The seven Spirits are sent out into all the earth to make his victory effective throughout the world. This can be related with the two witnesses in Rev.11:3-13. The relationship depends again on allusions to Zachariah 4, which John interprets in Rev.11:3-4. The two olive trees of Zachariah’s vision are the two anointed ones who stand by the Lord (Zech.4:14). Revelation’s two witnesses are the two olive trees and the two lampstands that stand before the Lord (Rev.11:4). The implication is that the seven Spirits are the power of the church’s prophetic witness to the world symbolize by the ministry of the two witnesses. This witness is suggested by the phrase John borrows from Zechariah that they stand before the Lord of the earth, which also relates their universal witness to Christ’s lordship of the world. So it is through their prophetic witness that the seven Spirits are sent out into all the earth.[15]  

2. The Unique Ministry of the Spirit to the Churches:
One important function and ministry of the Spirit is to communicate the messages of God and Jesus through the gift of prophecy (Rev.1:10; 4:2; 17:3; 19:10; 21:10). The Spirit speaks to the church and each of the messages to the churches contains the phrase “He who has an ear, let him hear what the Spirit says to the churches” (Rev.2:7, 11, 17, 29; 3:6, 13, 22). These messages are exhortatory and usually contain promises or revelations about God’s plan for the churches. In Revelation we see Jesus speaking to His church through Jesus and the Spirit, the voice and presence of Christ within the church. He blesses the church (Rev.14:13), gives believers grace and peace (Rev.1:4), and is directly involved in the mission of the church (Rev.22:17). The church exists through the power and presence of the Spirit.[16] The sevenfold exhortation emphasises two particular matters; first, although the letter has been addressed to the whole assembly, it is incumbent upon each believer in the local assembly to give heed to the searching ministry, and second, the message is the voice of the Spirit of God to all the assemblies. These two matters carry great weight to any exercised believer, it is ever important in all public reading and ministry of the Word of God that each individual should pay heed to it. The phrase is emphasising that the human ear is the instrument through which the message is received, but the exhortation is toward the active exercise of truly hearing and responding to what is being said by the Spirit of God.[17]

3. The Throne and the Spirit: 
In Revelation the Spirit is not described as sitting on the throne of God. There are four main reasons for this. First, the emphasis placed on Christ sitting on the throne with God is based on the fact that He overcame the forces of evil. Jesus ascended to heaven and was granted the honor of sitting on the throne as coregent with God (Rev.5:12, 13). Second, the Spirit is indeed associated with the throne. He stands before it (Rev.4:5), and when the Lamb stands before the throne He is described as having the seven Spirits of God, that is to say the fullness of the Spirit (Rev.5:6).[18] Third, even though the Spirit stands before the throne, He does not participate in the adoration of God and the Lamb. Only the four living beings and the 24 elders prostrate themselves before them and worship (Rev.4:9, 10). Fourth, in Revelation the function of the Spirit within the divine economy of salvation is not to sit on the throne, but to be present in the world and with the church. He is “the seven Spirits of God sent out into all the earth” (Rev.5:6). He has become a Servant of God, standing before Him to obey His command (Rev.1:4).[19]

4. The Spirit and the Eschatological Perspective:
The eschatological activity of the Spirit in the world derives from the victory of Christ in his death and resurrection (Rev.5:6). So it is towards the fulfilment of this victory in the eschatological future that the Spirit’s activity in and through the churches is directed. This eschatological role of the Spirit’s activity in the Apocalypse is not simply that of predicting the events of the end. It is also to enable the Christians of the seven churches to bear witness of Jesus and this could be done by directing their lives towards the coming of the Lord. The point here is not to enable them to foresee the future but to enable them to see their present from the perspective of the future.[20] We will see two passages to illustrate in which the Spirit is specifically mentioned.

4.1. Revelation 22:17
In this verse we can see that the Spirit and the bride are mentioned. The bride is the church which the Lamb will find ready for his marriage when he comes. The bride is the church seen from the perspective of the parousia. The church which prays for the Lord’s coming in Rev.22:17 is therefore the eschatological church, the church which will be at the parousia. In this prayer it is led by the voice of the Spirit speaking through the prophets, for the function of the Spirit is to direct the church towards their eschatological reality. The hearer of the prophecy is then invited to join in this prayer of the Spirit and the Bride, and as he joins his own voice to that of the Spirit the eschatological church is becoming present reality already (in the congregations at Ephesus, Smyrna or wherever). By eliciting this response the Spirit is making ready the Bride for the Bridegroom’s return.[21] Christian life must be lived under the Spirit’s direction towards the eschatological future out of which the Lord is coming. People who join the Spirit’s prayer for the parousia are directing their lives in faith towards that promise.[22]

4.2. Revelation 11:3-13
The reference to the Spirit here is in 11:8 where it refers to Spirit-given perception. The story of the witnesses here in Rev.11:3-13 is to be read neither as simple prediction nor as allegory nor even as parable. Rather it is a story through which the churches are to perceive imaginatively, through the perspective granted them by the Spirit, their vocation and their destiny.  Like Rev.22:17, the story functions as a summons towards the eschatological future.[23] The role of the Spirit in directing Christian life towards the parousia and the role of the Spirit in inspiring those who bear the witness of Jesus come together in this story which crystallizes one of the major messages of the prophecy. There is a dimension to the story of the witnesses. It is clear that it follows not only precedents from Old Testament history but also more closely the history of Jesus, who shared the fate of the prophets before him. Here in this passage, the witnesses’ resurrection after three and a half days and their ascension in a cloud deliberately recall Jesus’ resurrection and ascension. In this way the story permits a vivid representation of the faithful witness’s identification with Jesus in his witness and his death, and also in his vindication.[24]

5. The Role of the Spirit in Revelation:
One must be able first to understand the symbolic language in which some of the descriptions of the role of the Spirit are expressed. By giving the symbolic value of the number seven in Revelation, one can understand the attempt to portray the perfection of the Spirit by its seven-fold representation.[25] The setting is symbolic in Rev.3:1, where the seven Spirits of God are paralleled with the seven stars in Jesus’ right hand, as well as in Rev.4:5, where the seven Spirits of God are represented as seven lamps of fire burning before the throne, and in Rev.5:6, where the seven-fold Spirit of God is represented as seven eyes on the Lamb which are sent out into all the earth.[26] In Rev.3:18, 23 we have seen how the eyes of the Son of God are significant for their ability to search the mind and the heart. This is the work of the Spirit, as indicated in Rev.5:6 and its allusions to 2 Chron. 16:9 and Zech 4:10. Revelation brings all of this together to depict the function of the seven-fold Spirit of God in the presence of the Lord of all the earth.[27]

The function of the Spirit in Revelation is to represent God and Christ to the people of earth, to make God’s work effective on earth, to bring the light of truth to the world, to engender prophecy and faithful witness, to search the hearts and minds of people, and to bring conviction of truth forcefully to the mind. The appeal is given at the end of each of the letters to the seven churches, “He who has an ear, let him hear what the Spirit says to the churches” (Rev.2:7, 11, 17, 29; 3:6, 13, 22). The Spirit becomes the voice of conscience, the voice of Christ spoken internally to the heart and mind. He is depicted as searching the heart and mind.[28] In the message of Christ to the church of Sardis, He introduces Himself as the One who has the seven Spirits of God (Rev.3:1) because the church of Sardis is nearly dead, and it is the Spirit who gives life to the dead. The Spirit is called “the spirit of life” that is to say, He is life and He gives life. In the Bible life is identified with God and Jesus.[29] In Rev 22:17, the Spirit and the Bride invite everyone who is thirsty to come and take of the water of life freely. The water of life flows from the throne of God and of the Lamb (Rev.22:1) and brings life wherever it goes (v. 2; cf. Ezek 47:1, 9, 12). In this invitation we see the work of the Holy Spirit in appealing to the hearts of people to come to life, which God offers freely from His throne of grace and mercy.[30]
The Spirit is represented several times in Revelation in its function of communicating a prophetic message through visions and auditions to the mind of the prophet. The Spirit also speaks in Rev.14:13 to confirm the voice that comes from heaven regarding those who die in the Lord, adding, “…so that they may rest from their labours, for their deeds follow with them.” This testimony about the role of the Spirit is in harmony with the rest of Scripture about His role in communicating God’s messages to the hearts and minds of people on earth. This role is equivalent in Revelation to the role which Jesus described for Him in John 14- 16. We can see a work of comforting and counselling, of reminding and convicting, of guiding and teaching, of doing the work of Christ in His absence to help to prepare His followers for the judgment and for Christ’s return to reward those who have been faithful to Him. As the Communicator of God’s will and His grace to humanity, the Holy Spirit does not exalt Himself, but He exalts the Father and the Son. Yet, the Spirit is portrayed as a full member of the heavenly Trinity.[31]

6. Holy Spirit in relation to Indian Christian Theology:
In stating the books of The Theology of Chenchiah, Thangasamy said that Chenchiah goes beyond all the traditional, dogmatic categories that rent the Church, and completely revolutionises the idea of the Holy Spirit. For him, the Holy Spirit transcends all historical limitations and surpasses all geographical boundaries and becomes the Paramapurusha and Antharyamin, the universal dweller in the hearts of men. The Holy Spirit meets the spiritual thirst and cravings of the age-long need of the human heart.[32] This has some similar concepts on the Holy Spirit in the book of Revelation. In Rev 22:17, the Spirit invite everyone who is thirsty to come and take of the water of life freely. Moreover, the Spirit becomes the voice of conscience, the voice of Christ spoken internally to the heart and mind. He is depicted as searching the heart and mind.[33] Thangasamy continue to say that, in the Church the Holy Spirit revitalises its whole thinking by equipping the church with the gifts to go into the world and carry on a challenging ministry. The Church as the body of Christ is indwelt by the Holy Spirit and the Holy Spirit gives a new impetus and breathes new life into church.[34] Likewise, the ministry of the Spirit is to communicate the messages of God and Jesus through the gift of prophecy (Rev.1:10; 4:2; 17:3; 19:10; 21:10). These messages are exhortatory and usually contain promises or revelations about God’s plan for the churches.[35] It is the Holy Spirit who inspires and equipped the believers to bore witnesses to the testimony of Jesus Christ to spread His Good news to the whole world.

Conclusion:
It is noteworthy that the Spirit plays a significant role in the book of Revelation. The book itself begins and ends with references to the Spirit in Rev. 1:4 and Rev.22:17. We have also seen that the Spirit of God as the agent of visionary experience is occasional in the Old Testament (Num.24:2). More important are the prominence of the Spirit in Ezekiel’s experiences of visionary rapture (Eze.3:2, 14, 8:3, 11:1 etc) and the specification of dreams and visions as the manifestation of the eschatological outpouring of the Spirit in Joel 2:28. It is the Spirit that inspires prophetic speech and visions. The Spirit in Revelation is also the spirit of prophecy. The Spirit of prophecy speaks through the Christian prophets bringing the word of the exalted Christ to his people on earth and directing the prayers of the churches to their heavenly Lord. It is also to be noted that Revelation mention of the seven spirits is unique. The implication is that the seven Spirits are the power of the church’s prophetic witness to the world symbolize by the ministry of the two witnesses. The Spirit also communicates the message of God to the churches. We also notice that the Spirit has a role in the eschatological perspectives in a way that the eschatological activity of the Spirit in the world derives from the victory of Christ in his death and resurrection. Finally, the function of the Spirit in Revelation is to represent God and Christ to the people of earth, to make God’s work effective on earth, to bring the light of truth to the world, to engender prophecy and faithful witness, to search the hearts and minds of people, and to bring conviction of truth forcefully to the mind.
------------------------------------------------------------



Bibliography:

Baker, J.R. “The Holy Spirit in Revelation.” In Interpretation (2006): 1-8.    
Bauckham, R.  “The Role of the Spirit in the Apocalypse.” In The Evangelical Quarterly 52/2       (April/June, 1980): 1-14.
_______. The Theology of the Book of the New Testament. Cambridge: Cambridge             University Press, 1993.
_______. The Climax of Prophecy: Studies on the Book of Revelation. New York: T&T      Clark, 1993.
Bruce, F.F. “The Spirit in the Apocalypse.” In Christ and Spirit in the New Testament. Edited       by B. Lindars and S.S. Smalley. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973.
Davis, J.J. Biblical Numerology: A Basic Study of the Use of Numbers in the Bible. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker, 1968.
Fiorenza, E.S. “The eschatology and composition of the Apocalypse.” In The Catholic Bible         Quarterly 30 (1968): 561-563.  
Hill, D. “Prophecy and Prophets in the Revelation of St. John.” In New Testament Studies 18        (1972): 401-418.
Reynolds, E. “The Trinity in the Book of Revelation.” In Journal of the Adventist   Theological Society 17/1 (Spring, 2006): 55-72.
Rodríguez, A.M. “The Holy Spirit in Revelation.” In Biblical Research Institute (2016): 1-4.
Singh, B. The Holy Spirit: His work and Significance as revealed in the Book of Revelation.           Hyderabad: Hebron, 1999.
Swete, H.B. The Apocalypse of St. John. London: McMillan, 1997.
Thangasamy, D.A. The Theology of Chenchiah. Bangalore: CISRS/YMCA, 1966.


[1] Richard Baukham, The Climax of Prophecy: Studies on the Book of Revelation (New York: T&T Clark, 1993), 150.
[2] The references are Rev.1:10, 4:2, 17:3, 21:10. However though in each case the references is to John’s experience as a prophetic visionary, the precise meaning is not the same in each case. See Baukham, Climax of Prophecy, 150.
[3] Baukham, Climax of Prophecy, 151-152.
[4] E.g. are 1 Enoch 91:1, Jub 25:14, 31:12, Pseudo-Philo, LAB 18:11, 32:14, 4 Ezra 14:22, Sir 48:24).
[5] Some of the comparison passages from the Jewish and early Christian writings are 1 Kings 18:12, 2 Kings 2:16, Ezekiel 3:12, 14, 8:3, 11:1, 24, 37:1, 43:5, Bel 36, 2 Baruch 6:3, Acts 8:39-40, Gospel of Hebrews 2:12, Hermas, visions 1:13, 2:1:1.
[6] Baukham, Climax of Prophecy, 156-157.
[7] Baukham, Climax of Prophecy, 158-159.
[8] D. Hill, “Prophecy and Prophets in the Revelation of St. John,” in NTS 18 (1972): 411-412.
[9] Hill, “Prophecy and Prophets in the Revelation of St. John,” 414.
[10] Baukham, Climax of Prophecy, 163.
[11] Bakht Singh, The Holy Spirit: His work and Significance as revealed in the Book of Revelation (Hyderabad: Hebron, 1999), 22.
[12] Baukham, Climax of Prophecy, 163.
[13] Richard Bauckham, The Theology of the Book of the New Testament (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 111.
[14] Bauckham, Theology of the Book of the New Testament, 112.
[15] Bauckham, Theology of the Book of the New Testament, 113.
[16] Ángel Manuel Rodríguez, “The Holy Spirit in Revelation,” in BRI (2016): 2.
[17] James R. Baker, “The Holy Spirit in Revelation,” in Interpretation (2006): 3.
[18] Rodríguez, “Holy Spirit in Revelation,” 2.  
[19] Rodríguez, “Holy Spirit in Revelation,” 3.
[20] Richard J. Bauckham, “The Role of the Spirit in the Apocalypse,” in EQ 52/2 (April/June, 1980): 9.    
[21] H.B. Swete, The Apocalypse of St. John (London: McMillan, 1997), 310.
[22] Swete, Apocalypse of St. John, 310.
[23] E.S. Fiorenza, “The eschatology and composition of the Apocalypse,” in CBQ 30 (1968): 561-563.
[24] Bauckham, “Role of the Spirit in the Apocalypse,” 14.
[25] John J. Davis, Biblical Numerology: A Basic Study of the Use of Numbers in the Bible (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker, 1968), 116.
[26] F. F. Bruce, “The Spirit in the Apocalypse,” in Christ and Spirit in the New Testament (ed. Barnabas Lindars and Stephen S. Smalley; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973), 599.
[27] Bruce, “Spirit in the Apocalypse,” 599.
[28] Edwin Reynolds, “The Trinity in the Book of Revelation,” in JATS 17/1 (Spring, 2006): 69.
[29] Rodríguez, “Holy Spirit in Revelation,” 3.  
[30] Reynolds, “Trinity in the Book of Revelation,” 70.
[31] Reynolds, “Trinity in the Book of Revelation,” 71.
[32] D. A. Thangasamy, The Theology of Chenchiah (Bangalore: CISRS/YMCA, 1966), 218.
[33] Rodríguez, “Holy Spirit in Revelation,” 3.    
[34] Thangasamy, Theology of Chenchiah, 218.
[35] Rodríguez, “Holy Spirit in Revelation,” 3.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Slaves and their place in Early Christian Communities

Introduction: Throughout the history of humankind the slaves are the most pitied person because they have no independent of their own...